Hands on Review: Propper Starter Canned Starter Wort!
by Brad Probert, Homebrew Finds, Article Source
This review is by Homebrew Finds Contributor Brad Probert. Brad is an engineer, expert homebrewer and experienced reviewer.
Propper Starter Canned Starter Wort
I never used to be a fan of starters. I willfully ignored stories people would tell about their starters because I didn’t want starters to matter. Extra work strung out to a few days before brew day was something I just couldn’t get excited about. But then I did some experiments splitting a batch and fermenting one with a starter and one without. I then saw firsthand how the starter saved a couple of challenging lager fermentations. I could no longer be a denier.
I set about trying to make the process as easy as possible with a flask, stir plate, and even a small electric coffee kettle to allow me to keep the process contained to my basement brewing area. It was manageable, but I still couldn’t overcome the dislike of having to buy DME (and running short when I needed it), and the whole cooling process after I boiled the wort starter. Then I stumbled upon the Propper Starter canned starter wort in my LHBS. Could this be my savior?
Propper canned starter wort is made by Omega Yeast Labs. Omega yeast labs opened in mid-2013, which makes it a newer kid on the block of homebrewing yeast suppliers. Based in St. Louis and Chicago, you will mostly find their yeast in the Midwest and East Coast areas. A yeast producer making a yeast starter seems like a natural/logical fit.
The can of Propper Starter contains concentrated wort and yeast nutrient. It’s made to be diluted to the proper concentration. One 16 oz. can of concentrated wort poured into your flask, then you fill up the empty 16 oz. can with water again and you’ve got 1 Liter of 1.040 gravity starter wort.
Hands on Review
The process of making this starter is incredibly simple. The water you choose to use is where you can really rack up the time savings. You can use Reverse Osmosis, Distilled, or tap water (if you boil it first and then cool it down). The key here is making sure the water is microbe free. Boiling and chilling tap water to kill any microbes requires a lot of time and a lot of babysitting. I went and bought a gallon of Distilled water from the store so I could skip both the boiling and chilling steps. That gallon jug is good for 16 x 1L starters. The beauty here is that the jug of distilled water is already at room temperature, so it’s as simple as just pouring these together in the flask, dumping the yeast and putting it on the stir plate.
To quantify exactly how fast it is, I timed the process. First step involved my bottle of Star San spraying down the Propper Starter Can top, my Erlenmeyer flask, and the outside of my yeast pouch. I swirled the Star San around in my flask to ensure it got on every surface, then let the extra drain out. Poured it all together and put it on the stir plate, then stopped the timer. Five minutes and 26 seconds from start to finish. Doing it with DME and boiling/chilling water would consume about an hour of my time (depending on how hands-on I wanted to be on the chilling portion to make that go faster).
Time Trail Complete – 5 minutes and 26 seconds
I ran some numbers on the price. A 4-pack of Propper Starter cans sells for $12.99 at multiple different homebrew shops, so about $3.25 per 1 L of starter. My distilled water sells for $1.00/gallon at the grocery store. So a 2L starter will cost you $6.50 for the Propper Starter plus $0.25 of distilled water. Making a 2L starter with DME requires 7.5 oz. of DME to get 1.040 gravity. At a price of $5.50/lb for Golden Light Briess DME, that works out to $2.58 per 2L starter (assuming using “free” tap water).
So depending on what value you place on your time (or if you were theoretically paying a minimum wage high school student to make your starters) the Propper Starter works out to be worth the extra money spent for the time save.
The starter wort is a darker color than a Light DME starter. So if you’re brewing a very pale colored beer, you may want to cold crash and decant before pitching into your fermentor. Or the effect may be minimal based on volume ratio of starter to your beer volume. To test the gravity, I made two different 1L starter batches to evaluate. Both of them were spot on 1.040 gravity. I made the starter a few days before brew day and cold crashed and decanted. When pitched into my chilled wort at 50F, I saw gravity start to drop on my Tilt hydrometer 5 hours after pitching it. So it definitely made a very healthy starter.
Overall, the Propper Starter definitely delivers with a healthy pitch of yeast going into your fermentor. And if your objective is to cut time out of this process step, it definitely delivers. Aside from the actual measured time save of the prep process, it fundamentally changes it from something you need to carve out time to do, to something you can just run downstairs and take care of. And that can be transformational from making it a process you don’t do, to a process you do.
Finding Propper Starter Canned Wort
- Propper Starter Canned Wort via MoreBeer
- Propper Starter Canned Wort via Brewer Dude
- Propper Starter Canned Wort via Austin Homebrew Supply
- Propper Starter Canned Wort via Adventures in Homebrewing
- Propper Starter Canned Wort via Great Fermentations
Special Thanks to Omega Yeast Labs for providing the Propper Starter Canned Wort used for evaluation in this review.